江燕, 陈晓非. 2014: 有限频率线性理论的波恩近似佯谬. 地震学报, 36(3): 372-389. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.0253-3782.2014.03.004
引用本文: 江燕, 陈晓非. 2014: 有限频率线性理论的波恩近似佯谬. 地震学报, 36(3): 372-389. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.0253-3782.2014.03.004
Jiang Yan, Chen Xiaofei. 2014: Born approximation paradox of linear finite-frequency theory. Acta Seismologica Sinica, 36(3): 372-389. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.0253-3782.2014.03.004
Citation: Jiang Yan, Chen Xiaofei. 2014: Born approximation paradox of linear finite-frequency theory. Acta Seismologica Sinica, 36(3): 372-389. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.0253-3782.2014.03.004

有限频率线性理论的波恩近似佯谬

Born approximation paradox of linear finite-frequency theory

  • 摘要: 对有限频率层析成像线性理论的波恩近似问题进行梳理, 用数值方法统计分析其适用范围, 结果表明波恩近似要求最大速度扰动不超过1%; 然后对相关走时一阶近似进行统计分析, 结果表明它也只适用于最大速度扰动在1%以内的情形. 然而, 结合波恩近似和相关走时一阶近似而得到的有限频率线性理论, 其适用的速度扰动范围最大可达10%. 这个表面上的逻辑悖论, 称为“波恩近似佯谬”. 此佯谬是由于不恰当地使用波恩近似造成的. 本文摒弃波恩近似, 使用泛函的Fréchet微分和隐函数定理推导得到有限频率线性理论, 圆满解释了波恩近似佯谬. 由于有限频率非线性理论早已摒弃了波恩近似, 因此波恩近似概念在有限频率层析成像理论中完全没有必要.

     

    Abstract: After reviewing the Born approximation problem of linear finite-frequency tomography theory, its scope of application is statistically analyzed by numerical method. The result indicates that the maximum velocity perturbation should not exceed 1% for Born approximation. Then the statistical analyses on the first-order approximation of cross-correlation travel-time also show that it only meets the case of the maximum velocity perturbation less than 1%. However, the maximum velocity perturbation can be 10% for linear finite-frequency theory, which combines Born approximation with the first-order approximation of cross-correlation travel-time. This apparent logic paradox is called “Born approximation paradox”, which is caused by misusage of Born approximation. Thus, Born approximation is discarded in this study; Fréchet derivative and implicit functional theorem are used to deduce linear finite-frequency theory. As a result, Born approximation paradox is explained thoroughly. Since Born approximation has been discarded early in nonlinear finite-frequency theory, this concept is unnecessary in finite-frequency tomography theory.

     

/

返回文章
返回